Interview Guide for Hiring Managers and Employers
The hiring manager is the front line of hiring for a business. They assess applicants, schedule interviews, score candidates and make the final hiring decision. But hiring managers do more than sift through candidates. They’re also a face of the business, responsible for building a hiring process that attracts the right people. How to Prepare for a Job Interview as a Hiring Manager Defining Selection Criteria Before Interviews Define your selection criteria and what your ideal candidate looks like before you begin interviews. One of the most common mistakes that hiring managers and employers make is not having a clearly defined list of the objective characteristics and experience they’re looking for in an ideal candidate. What’s more, as you move through the interview process, it’s easy for recency bias to creep in and for early interviewees to be forgotten or overshadowed. Using an objective selection criteria ensures you come away from each interview with a clear score that can be used to consistently grade candidates. Reviewing Resumes Before an Interview The interview shouldn’t be the first time you’re reviewing the candidate’s resume. Everyone has sat in at least one interview where the hiring manager is fumbling their way through and frantically looking for information as the interview unfolds. This doesn’t just make a bad impression on the prospective candidate. It also means you’re not making the most of your time by asking probing questions about the experience and key information listed on their resume. Pre-Interview Checklist for Hiring Managers Have a clearly defined scorecard and selection criteria before starting the interviewsFor remote interviews, test all links and ensure you arrive at least 5-minutes before the meeting start time.Review the candidate's resume ahead of the interview and have questions ready to go.Grade each candidate against the selection criteria so that every interviewee receives a score at the end of the interview.Make relevant notes which may be used in a second interview or may be asked when doing a reference check at a later date.Ensure you have answers for common interview questions including:What are you looking for in a candidate?When is the start date?What is the salary range?What does the hiring process look like from here? How to Structure a Job Interview Structured vs Unstructured Interviews Structured interview A structured interview asks all candidates the same job-related questions and scores them based on their answers to those questions. Unstructured interview An unstructured interview, on the other hand, has a guide for the questions that need to be asked, but leaves room for conversation and rapport to be built. It’s up to the hiring manager whether interviews follow a structured or unstructured process, but the key is consistency in structure and grading. Structured interviews are the most effective for creating a consistent scorecard, but they don’t leave much room for building rapport with the candidate. On the other hand, an unstructured interview can be a good way to build rapport, uncover information about the candidate, and see how they interact in a more casual, work-like environment. How Many Interview Rounds to Run How many rounds of interviews you run depends on the job and the number of candidates. In most cases, two rounds of interviews will be suitable: a first round that runs for around 30 minutes and gives you the chance to go over the candidate’s resume and relevant experience, and a second round that’s more about how their experience fits into the role and goes over any questions they may have. It’s important to remember that the goal of interviewing is to hire. There’s no need to put candidates through unnecessary rounds of interviews just for the sake of it. Once you have enough information to make a decision, there’s no need to run more rounds. How Long a Job Interview Should Be A typical job interview will run anywhere from 30 to 60 minutes, depending on the role and the stage of the interview process. An initial screening interview could run for 15 minutes, whilst a third-round interview could run for 90 minutes or more, especially in cases where an interview project is being presented. As a general rule, an interview should run for as long or as short as it needs to for the hiring manager to ask all of the relevant questions and find out what they want to know about the interviewee. Who Should Sit on an Interview Panel An ideal interview panel includes three people/key groups: The hiring manager or team leader the new hire will report to.An HR representative or a stakeholder from another team who can assess culture fit, process consistency, or how the role will work with other departments.One employee who’s on the same level as the role being interviewed for. A three-person panel gives you the opportunity to ask questions from different perspectives and allows the panel to compare their initial assessments of the interviewee. Job Interview Formats for Employers Phone Screening Interviews An initial phone screening can last for 15 to 20 minutes and gives the hiring manager the opportunity to ask basic questions about the resume, field any questions the interviewee may have about the role and get a basic sense of their suitability for the position. Video Interviews Video interviews are becoming increasingly common, especially for roles where candidates are being interviewed from different cities or states. A video interview saves time for both parties and is an ideal format for a structured interview, where hiring managers can follow a script, ask the same questions and use the same scoring criteria for all prospective candidates. Panel Interviews A panel interview (like the one mentioned above) gives hiring managers the opportunity to reflect with other panellists, which is particularly useful where the other panellists are likely to be those working directly with the candidate. Task-Based Assessments and Work Samples A task-based assessment can be a really important part of the process, as it puts the candidate’s resume to the test. It gives hiring managers the opportunity to see how a candidate actually works on a project and assesses their performance against other candidates to give a realistic projection of how they’ll perform in the role. There’s a misplaced, school-of-hard-knocks idea that task-based assessments are a good way to separate those who are serious about the job from those who aren’t. And whilst there may be some truth to this, it’s important to use task-based assessments sparingly. Respect the candidate's time. Don’t use task-based assessments in the first round of interviews, or when you’re considering five or six different candidates. A task-based assessment is a last resort to sort out the final applicants for the role. Best Interview Questions to Ask Candidates Behavioural Interview Questions Behavioural interview questions invite candidates to share examples of how they’ve worked in the past, and how they’ve faced and overcome adversity in the workplace. Examples of behavioural interview questions include: Examples of Behavioural Interview Questions Tell me about a time when you dealt with conflict in the workplace.Tell me about a time when you excelled at a task.Tell me about a time when you disagreed with someone at work and how you handled that situation. Situational Interview Questions Situational interview questions ask candidates to explain how they would approach hypothetical situations in the workplace. The types of situational questions you ask depend on the role. Some examples may include: Examples of Situational Interview Questions How would you deal with negative feedback on a project you have completed?What would you do if a client called you and complained about a project that you had worked on?Imagine you are given an instruction from your manager that you know will negatively affect the outcome of your work. How would you navigate this situation? Competency-Based Interview Questions Competency-based interview questions evaluate the real-world skills of the person you’re interviewing. Instead of giving them hypothetical situations, you’re drawing on real-world workplace experiences. Examples of competency-based interview questions include: Examples of Competency-Based Interview Questions Tell me about a time when you have had to navigate conflict at work.Tell me about a time where you were able to work collaboratively to reach a deadline. Tell me about a challenging decision you made and how you arrived at the conclusion you did. Interview Questions About Motivation and Career Goals “Where do you see yourself in 3, 5, or 10 years?” is the classic question that comes to mind when we think about motivation and career goals. Other examples of motivation and career goal questions include: Examples of Interview Questions About Motivation and Career Goals: What would make this role fulfilling for you?What attracted you to this role and/or company?If you get this role, where do you see yourself 12 months from now? Interview Questions Employers Can't Ask in Australia When it comes to interviewing prospective employees, there are certain things that are off limits. Many of these are common sense, such as “What is your sexuality?”, “What is your ethnicity?”, “What is your gender identity?”. Outside of the more obvious off-limit questions, there are certain questions employers and hiring staff should avoid asking. These questions may be deemed discriminatory, as they seek personal information that an employer could potentially use to discriminate against someone when hiring. Examples of questions you can’t ask in an interview include: What is your marital status?Are you pregnant?Do you plan to have kids?Do you have any carer’s responsibilities?How old are you?What is your religion?Do you have any disabilities?What are your political beliefs?Are you a member of any special groups? There are some exceptions. You can ask about a disability if it relates to the inherent requirements of the job, such as whether a candidate can safely perform a physically demanding task. You can also ask about age where there’s a legal minimum for the role, such as serving alcohol. This is general information only and shouldn’t be taken as legal advice. If you’re unsure whether a question is appropriate, speak with an employment lawyer or contact the Fair Work Ombudsman. Common Interview Mistakes Hiring Managers Make Talking more than the candidate in order to fill any silences.Asking leading questions that guide the candidate.Relying on gut feel and not keeping track of interviewees using a standardised scorecard.Taking too long to make a hiring decision.Doing more rounds of interviews than necessary to find the right candidate.Letting recency bias creep into the hiring decision.Making a gut-feel decision before getting to know the candidate.
Read More